A beautiful custom cake can turn an ordinary gathering into a memorable celebration. Whether you’re planning a birthday party, baby shower, graduation, anniversary, wedding, or another special occasion, a custom celebration cake can serve as both a delicious dessert and a centerpiece for the event.

Ordering a custom cake can seem overwhelming if you’ve never done it before. There are flavors to choose from, cake sizes to consider, colors and decorations to coordinate, and sometimes a very specific design you have in mind.

The good news is that you don’t need to be a cake expert to order a great custom cake.

With a little planning, you can provide the important details your cake designer needs and make the process much easier.

This guide covers everything you should consider when ordering a custom celebration cake, from choosing the right size and flavor to selecting a design and planning when to place your order.

What Is a Custom Celebration Cake?

A custom celebration cake is a cake created specifically for an individual event or occasion.

Unlike a standard pre-designed cake, a custom cake can be personalized to match your celebration. The design can incorporate specific colors, themes, decorations, messages, names, ages, and other details.

Depending on the cake and the design, customization may include:

• Cake flavor
• Frosting flavor
• Filling
• Cake size
• Cake shape
• Number of tiers
• Colors
• Piping
• Flowers
• Sprinkles
• Decorative details
• Personalized messages
• Names
• Ages
• Themed decorations
• Cake toppers
• Textures and patterns

A custom cake can be simple and elegant or detailed and elaborate. The right design depends on the celebration and your personal preferences.

Step 1: Decide What You’re Celebrating

The first step is identifying the occasion.

Knowing what you’re celebrating makes it easier to determine the appropriate cake style, size, colors, and decorations.

Birthday Cakes

Birthday cakes can be designed around almost anything.

For children, popular designs may incorporate favorite colors, animals, hobbies, characters, toys, sports, or other interests.

Adult birthday cakes can range from elegant and sophisticated to fun and colorful. Floral designs, vintage-inspired cakes, minimalist decorations, and personalized themes can all make beautiful birthday cakes.

Baby Shower Cakes

Baby shower cakes often coordinate with the event’s color palette or theme.

Popular design elements can include:

• Soft colors
• Floral decorations
• Baby-themed details
• Names or initials
• Simple patterns
• Bows
• Hearts
• Seasonal flowers

If the shower already has decorations selected, bringing those colors and design elements into the cake can create a more coordinated dessert table.

Wedding and Bridal Cakes

Wedding cakes typically require additional planning because they often need to accommodate more guests and coordinate with the overall wedding design.

Consider the:

• Wedding colors
• Flowers
• Venue
• Table settings
• Invitations
• Wedding dress style
• Overall wedding theme

A cake doesn’t have to duplicate every wedding detail. Sometimes a few carefully selected elements are enough to create a cohesive look.

Graduation Cakes

Graduation cakes can celebrate an important milestone with personalized details.

Consider incorporating:

• School colors
• Graduation year
• Name
• Degree
• School logo or colors
• Graduation cap decorations
• Diplomas
• Personalized messages

Anniversary Cakes

Anniversary cakes can be elegant, romantic, playful, or highly personalized.

Consider using colors associated with the couple, meaningful flowers, a favorite flavor, initials, dates, or other details that have personal significance.

Holiday Cakes

Custom cakes can also be a fun addition to holiday celebrations.

Depending on the holiday, consider seasonal:

• Colors
• Shapes
• Decorations
• Flavors
• Patterns
• Characters
• Themes

Step 2: Determine How Many People the Cake Should Serve

Before choosing a cake, estimate your guest count.

This is one of the most important details to provide when ordering a custom cake.

A cake for eight people is going to be very different from a cake for 40 or 50 people.

Think about:

• How many guests will attend
• Whether children are included
• Whether other desserts will be available
• Whether you want leftovers
• Whether the cake is the main dessert
• Whether the cake is primarily intended as a centerpiece

Cake servings can vary based on the cake’s size, shape, height, and how it is cut.

If you’re unsure about what size you need, provide your cake designer with the number of guests and let them help determine an appropriate size.

Don’t Choose a Cake Based Only on Appearance

A cake can look large in photographs but serve fewer people than expected depending on its dimensions and construction.

When you’re ordering for a larger event, always think about servings rather than simply choosing a cake that looks large enough.

For weddings and other large celebrations, your cake designer can help determine how many tiers or additional sheet cakes may be appropriate.

Step 3: Choose Your Cake Flavor

Once you’ve determined the size, it’s time to think about flavor.

Classic flavors remain popular for a reason, but custom cakes give you the opportunity to try something different.

Some common choices include:

• Vanilla
• Chocolate
• Red velvet
• Strawberry
• Lemon
• Funfetti
• Marble
• Carrot cake

You may also have choices for fillings and frosting.

For example, vanilla cake can be paired with vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream, fruit fillings, or other complementary flavors.

Think About Your Guests

If you’re ordering a cake for a large group, consider flavors that will appeal to a variety of people.

For smaller celebrations, choosing a more adventurous flavor can be a fun way to personalize the cake.

If you can’t decide between two flavors, ask whether multiple flavors can be incorporated into the order.

Step 4: Choose the Frosting

Frosting isn’t just decoration. It contributes significantly to the overall flavor and texture of the cake.

Buttercream is a popular choice for custom cakes because it can be used for a wide range of finishes and decorations.

Depending on the cake design, frosting can be:

• Smooth
• Textured
• Piped
• Swirled
• Ruffled
• Floral
• Vintage-inspired
• Minimalist

The frosting color can also be customized to coordinate with the event.

Consider the Cake’s Environment

If your event will be outdoors or in a warm environment, talk with your cake designer about the best way to handle the cake.

Temperature and direct sunlight can affect certain frosting and decorative elements.

Plan ahead for how the cake will be transported, stored, and displayed.

Step 5: Select the Cake Shape

Round cakes are a classic choice, but they’re not your only option.

Depending on the design, you might choose:

• Round
• Square
• Heart-shaped
• Sheet cake
• Tiered
• Sculpted
• Custom-shaped

The shape can complement the theme of the celebration.

A heart-shaped cake may work well for an anniversary, while a tiered cake can create an impressive centerpiece for a wedding or large celebration.

Step 6: Decide on Your Cake Style

Now comes one of the most creative parts of ordering a custom cake: deciding what you want it to look like.

Start by thinking about the overall style.

Would you prefer something:

• Elegant
• Modern
• Simple
• Colorful
• Romantic
• Playful
• Vintage-inspired
• Rustic
• Glamorous
• Whimsical

You don’t have to know exactly what you want before contacting a cake designer.

Sometimes having a general direction is enough.

For example, you might simply say:

“I want a simple pink and white birthday cake with flowers.”

That gives the cake designer a starting point while leaving room for the design to come together.

Step 7: Gather Inspiration

Cake photographs can be extremely helpful when explaining your vision.

Before ordering, save a few examples that show the styles you like.

You might collect inspiration for:

• Color combinations
• Frosting styles
• Piping
• Flowers
• Cake shapes
• Textures
• Lettering
• Decorations
• Overall design

Pinterest, Instagram, cake galleries, and bakery websites can all provide inspiration.

Use Inspiration as a Starting Point

It’s helpful to distinguish between inspiration and an exact copy.

A photograph can show your cake designer the colors, style, or decorative techniques you like without requiring the exact same cake.

You can also combine ideas from several different cakes.

For example, you might like the colors from one cake, the frosting style from another, and the floral decorations from a third.

Step 8: Choose Your Colors

Color can dramatically change the appearance of a cake.

Think about the colors already being used at the event.

You may want your cake to coordinate with:

• Table decorations
• Balloons
• Flowers
• Invitations
• Party decorations
• Wedding colors
• Clothing
• Event themes

You don’t necessarily need to match everything perfectly.

A cake using complementary colors can look more interesting than one that simply copies every color from the room.

Step 9: Decide Whether You Want a Cake Message

A personalized message can add an extra special touch.

Depending on the occasion, your cake might include:

• Happy Birthday
• Congratulations
• Happy Anniversary
• A name
• An age
• A date
• Initials
• A short personal message

Keep in mind that cakes have limited space.

Shorter messages are usually easier to read and incorporate into the overall design.

Step 10: Consider Additional Desserts

Your cake doesn’t have to be the only dessert at the celebration.

Custom dessert tables can include several different treats.

Consider pairing your cake with:

• Cupcakes
• Cookies
• Cakesicles
• Brownies
• Cake pops
• Chocolate-covered treats
• Other bite-sized desserts

Coordinating the colors and decorations across several desserts can create a beautiful dessert table.

For example, a birthday cake can be paired with matching cupcakes and decorated sugar cookies.

A baby shower might include a custom cake with coordinating cakesicles and cookies.

Step 11: Order Your Cake Early

One of the most important things to remember is to give yourself enough time.

Custom cakes take planning, preparation, baking, decorating, and sometimes special-order ingredients or decorations.

How far ahead you should order depends on:

• Cake size
• Design complexity
• Event date
• Number of cakes
• Number of desserts
• Decorations
• Availability of the cake designer

Simple cakes may require less planning than elaborate multi-tiered or highly customized designs.

If you have a specific event date, it’s a good idea to contact the cake designer as early as possible rather than waiting until the last minute.

Especially Plan Ahead for Weddings

Wedding cakes often require more advance planning than everyday celebration cakes.

There may be additional considerations involving:

• Multiple tiers
• Cake tasting
• Delivery
• Venue requirements
• Cake table setup
• Floral coordination
• Serving size
• Decorative details

If you’re planning a wedding, start the cake conversation early enough to allow time for design decisions and scheduling.

Step 12: Set a Budget

Custom cakes can vary considerably in price depending on their size, ingredients, design, decorations, and amount of detail.

Before ordering, establish a general budget.

Be sure to consider that a highly detailed cake may require significantly more time and labor than a simple design.

Factors that can affect the price may include:

• Cake size
• Number of servings
• Number of tiers
• Flavor choices
• Fillings
• Frosting
• Decorative details
• Specialty ingredients
• Custom toppers
• Edible decorations
• Delivery
• Setup

A budget doesn’t have to limit your creativity.

Instead, it gives your cake designer useful information so they can help you determine which design elements are most important.

Step 13: Communicate Your Ideas Clearly

Good communication makes the ordering process easier for everyone.

When contacting a cake designer, provide as many of the following details as possible:

• Event date
• Event type
• Number of guests
• Cake flavor
• Preferred frosting
• Cake size
• Desired colors
• Theme
• Design inspiration
• Personalized message
• Delivery information
• Budget range

You don’t have to have every detail figured out.

Even if you only know the event date, guest count, colors, and general style, that’s enough to begin the conversation.

What Information Should You Include When Ordering?

A simple checklist can help make sure you don’t forget anything.

Custom Cake Order Checklist

Event

• What are you celebrating?
• What is the event date?

Guests

• How many people will attend?
• Will other desserts be served?

Cake

• What flavor?
• What size?
• What shape?
• One tier or multiple tiers?

Frosting

• What frosting flavor?
• What color?
• Smooth or textured?

Design

• What colors?
• What theme?
• Any flowers or decorations?
• Any inspiration photos?

Personalization

• Name?
• Age?
• Date?
• Message?
• Initials?

Logistics

• Pickup or delivery?
• Where will the cake be displayed?
• What time is the event?

Having these details ready can make the ordering process much smoother.

How to Transport a Custom Cake

Once your beautiful cake is finished, getting it safely to the celebration is just as important as ordering it.

Whenever possible, keep the cake level during transportation.

A few general tips include:

• Keep the cake in a secure cake box.
• Place it on a flat surface.
• Avoid placing it on a vehicle seat where it can slide.
• Drive carefully around turns.
• Avoid sudden braking.
• Keep the cake away from direct sunlight.
• Keep temperature-sensitive cakes appropriately cool.

Your cake designer may provide specific transportation instructions based on the cake’s design.

Follow those instructions carefully.

How to Store a Custom Cake

Storage instructions can vary depending on the ingredients and decorations.

Some cakes are best kept refrigerated, while others may be intended to remain at room temperature for a period of time.

Always follow the storage instructions provided with your specific cake.

If refrigeration is recommended, allow enough time for the cake to reach an appropriate serving temperature before the event when applicable.

Avoid repeatedly moving the cake between warm and cold environments.

How to Display Your Cake

The cake table can become an important part of the overall celebration.

Consider placing the cake where guests can easily see it.

A simple cake stand can elevate the presentation.

You can also coordinate the cake table with:

• Flowers
• Candles
• Balloons
• Tablecloths
• Dessert trays
• Personalized signs
• Coordinating cupcakes
• Cookies
• Cakesicles

The goal isn’t necessarily to fill the table with decorations. A clean, coordinated display can make the cake stand out.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Ordering a custom cake should be exciting, but there are a few common mistakes worth avoiding.

Waiting Until the Last Minute

Custom cakes require planning, especially when the design is detailed or the event falls during a busy season.

Not Providing the Guest Count

Your cake designer needs to know approximately how many people you’re serving to recommend an appropriate size.

Choosing a Design Without Considering the Venue

A delicate outdoor cake may require different considerations than a cake displayed inside an air-conditioned venue.

Providing Too Many Conflicting Ideas

Inspiration is helpful, but dozens of completely different cake designs can make it difficult to establish a clear direction.

Choose a few examples that demonstrate the look you’re going for.

Forgetting Transportation

A beautiful cake still needs to arrive safely.

Make sure you know whether the cake will be picked up or delivered and how it should be handled.

How to Make Your Custom Cake Personal

The best custom cake doesn’t necessarily have the most decorations.

Sometimes the smallest personal details make the biggest difference.

Consider incorporating:

• A favorite color
• A meaningful flower
• A favorite flavor
• A hobby
• A nickname
• A special date
• A favorite pattern
• A family tradition
• A short personal message

For children’s cakes, consider their interests.

For adult celebrations, think about hobbies, favorite colors, travel, careers, or other meaningful details.

For weddings, consider incorporating subtle elements from the couple’s overall wedding design.

Custom Cakes Don’t Have to Be Elaborate

One misconception about custom cakes is that they have to be extremely complicated.

A simple cake can still be completely customized.

For example, a smooth white cake with carefully piped flowers and a personalized message can create an elegant celebration cake without requiring an elaborate theme.

Likewise, a simple buttercream cake can be customized through color, texture, size, shape, and decoration.

Sometimes less really is more.

Questions to Ask Your Cake Designer

If you’re ordering a custom cake for the first time, don’t be afraid to ask questions.

Useful questions may include:

• What cake sizes are available?
• How many people does each size serve?
• What flavors are available?
• What frosting options are available?
• Can the colors be customized?
• Can I provide inspiration photos?
• How far in advance should I order?
• Do you offer delivery?
• How should the cake be transported?
• How should the cake be stored?
• Are custom messages available?
• Can the cake be coordinated with cupcakes or cookies?

A good cake-ordering experience starts with clear communication.

Final Custom Cake Planning Checklist

Before placing your order, make sure you’ve considered:

• Occasion: What are you celebrating?
• Date: When do you need the cake?
• Guest count: How many people will you serve?
• Flavor: What cake flavor do you want?
• Frosting: What frosting and filling do you prefer?
• Size: What size cake will you need?
• Shape: Round, square, heart, tiered, or another shape?
• Colors: What colors should be incorporated?
• Theme: Is there a particular theme?
• Design: What overall style do you want?
• Personalization: Do you want a name, age, date, or message?
• Inspiration: Do you have reference photos?
• Budget: What price range are you comfortable with?
• Delivery: Will the cake be delivered or picked up?
• Storage: How should the cake be stored before the event?

Final Thoughts

Ordering a custom celebration cake doesn’t have to be complicated.

Start with the basics: determine what you’re celebrating, how many people you’re serving, what flavors you enjoy, and what general style you want. From there, you can work through the colors, decorations, personalization, and other details.

The most helpful thing you can do is communicate your ideas clearly while remaining open to suggestions from your cake designer.

Whether you’re looking for a simple birthday cake, an elegant anniversary cake, a colorful baby shower cake, or a centerpiece for a wedding, a custom cake can make the celebration feel even more personal.

At Allison Holbrook Cakes, you can explore a variety of custom cakes and desserts designed for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, holidays, and other special occasions. You can also coordinate your cake with cupcakes, cakesicles, and cookies for a complete dessert table.

SEO Information

SEO Title: The Ultimate Guide to Ordering Custom Celebration Cakes | Allison Holbrook Cakes

Meta Description: Learn how to order the perfect custom celebration cake. Discover tips for choosing cake size, flavors, frosting, designs, colors, themes, and personalized details.

Suggested URL Slug:
ultimate-guide-ordering-custom-celebration-cakes

Primary Keyword: custom celebration cakes

Secondary Keywords:

how to order a custom cake

custom cakes

custom birthday cakes

celebration cake ideas

custom cake ordering

personalized cakes

custom cake designs

birthday cake ideas

custom wedding cakes

custom baby shower cakes